I want to ask you a very basic question — the sort of thing everyone thinks they know the answer to, but one that I've found surprisingly hard to answer: what is willpower?

People have held a number of different views on this over the years. To some people, willpower is a sort of intrinsic, boundless power of the soul from which anyone can draw as much strength as they require if they only try. That theory breaks down pretty quickly if you look at real-world outcomes. I've worked with many people over the years who were so addicted, so depressed, or so traumatized that they had very little willpower to speak of. Self-help programs that focus on rigid application of willpower rarely work, and often lead to burnout, so it seems clear to me that willpower isn't boundless.

A more common modern interpretation is that willpower works more like a gas tank — or what I've heard referred to as "spoon theory." The idea is that people have a limited number of "spoonfuls" of mental energy which they must ration throughout their day. Maybe you have ten spoons for the day: you spend five on work, two on chores, two on the kids — so that doesn't leave you much leftover for whatever else you might want to do that day. If you want to work on a new project, then, the solution is redistribution: scaling back at work, getting a babysitter for the kids, asking your spouse to handle more of the household chores, etc. There is certainly some truth to this — that energy is a limited resource, we know from the laws of thermodynamics — but I still think it is incomplete. I wonder if you, the reader, can recall a time where you felt very depleted, and then something happened or your attitude shifted, and you soon found yourself feeling surprisingly energized?

Take the body as an example: the way our energy level fluctuates throughout the day isn't as simple as waking up with 100 and going to bed with zero. Not only can the choices we make seriously affect our long-term energy from day-to-day, but various choices and stimuli can cause us to generate additional energy. If you expend more energy than you take in, then your body will burn fat, and at a certain point you won't feel so hungry. You might be ready to drop at 9 PM after a long day, but stay up a while longer, especially if you start thinking about something that excites you, and you will often get a second-wind — which might even cause problems because you're now too wound up to sleep!

Just by looking around us, we can see for ourselves that some people seem to have more willpower than others, just as some people are more physically energetic than others. But what are the reasons behind this? With regards to physical energy, we actually do know some of the correlating factors: good sleep, physical activity and health, high extraversion, and a strong sense of purpose have all been shown to correlate with higher subjective energy levels.

One thing that all of these have in common (except sleep, I suppose) is that they have less to do with gaining more energy than they do with how and why you expend it. That's a fascinating idea to me, because it means that there are two different layers that we can explore to improve our energy — and perhaps gain more willpower too. On the physical layer, we can practice better sleep habits, diet and exercise, and maintain an active lifestyle. On the mental layer, we can maintain a healthy social network, pursue individual passions, and perhaps most interesting of all: seek meaning and purpose in life.

I think this last one is probably a lot more important than we give credit for, because I've come to realize that meaning is such a fundamental drive in life. I'm a huge fan of Dr. Viktor Frankl, the author of Man's Search for Meaning, which he wrote following his experiences as a survivor of the Holocaust. According to Frankl, meaning is the most basic, fundamental drive of humankind — as opposed to Alfred Adler, who believed it was power, or Freud, who believed it was pleasure. Inside the concentration camps, Frankl said that those who were able to find some meaning in their suffering were usually the ones most able to survive, even when they were less physically robust than others. "In some way," Frankl writes, "suffering ceases to be suffering at the moment it finds a meaning, such as the meaning of a sacrifice."

Time and energy — which is to say, work — are also a sacrifice. So perhaps it shouldn't be surprising that meaning and passion seem to multiply willpower. The next logical question would be, "how do we multiply meaning and passion?" An excellent topic for next week, perhaps. For now, my takeaway is that the pursuit of meaning and truth creates the internal conditions under which energy and willpower thrives.

Have a blessed, wonderful day!
Dr. Alex Loyd

Alex

Add a Comment

Stay Connected with Dr. Alex

Sign Up for Dr. Alex’s Newsletter